On this page
- The Itch
- Is There a Free TradingSim Alternative?
- TradingSim vs Traders Journal at a Glance
- How We Compared
- Who TradingSim Is Built For
- What TradingSim Does Better
- Where Traders Journal Is the Better Fit
- Replay Speed and How Many Reps You Get
- What a Practice Stop Costs on Index Futures
- Switching From TradingSim: 3 Steps
- Other TradingSim Alternatives Worth Knowing
- Which Should You Pick?

Key takeaways
- TradingSim costs $33 a month (Pro) or $37 (Premium), billed annually, with a 7-day trial (checked 19 November 2026).
- It is the stronger pick for US stocks, Level 2 and tick charts. It does not list forex.
- Traders Journal has a free plan with 10 replay sessions a day, plus Premium at $12 a month or $119 a year.
- Neither tool is a profit promise. Replay enough sessions to have a sample, and log every trade.
Quick answer: TradingSim is a strong replay simulator for US stocks, and its plans start at $33 a month billed annually, with a 7-day trial. If you trade forex, gold or CME index futures, Traders Journal is the TradingSim alternative worth trying: a free plan with 10 replay sessions a day, Premium at $12 a month, and a journal that logs every practice trade. If US stocks are your game, stay with TradingSim. Checked on TradingSim's plans page on 19 November 2026.
Is There a Free TradingSim Alternative?
Yes, with a catch. TradingSim has a 7-day trial, then paid plans. Traders Journal has a free plan that does not expire: 10 replay sessions a day, one symbol, and a 90-day range on 1-minute candles. It covers forex, gold, oil, crypto, CME and CBOT E-mini NQ, ES and YM, and Indian indices. It does not replay individual US stocks or options.
So the real question is not free versus paid. It is which market you practise on. If your answer is "Apple, Tesla and the open", the specialist wins. If it is "EUR/USD, gold or Nasdaq futures", you may not need to pay $33 a month to find out.
TradingSim vs Traders Journal at a Glance
| Feature | TradingSim | Traders Journal |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Pro $33 a month, Premium $37 a month, both billed annually | Free plan. Premium $12 a month or $119 a year, 21-day trial |
| Free option | 7-day trial | Free plan, no end date |
| Markets | US stocks, futures, crypto (about 21,700 symbols) | Forex, gold, oil, crypto, index futures and CFDs, NIFTY and BANKNIFTY |
| US stocks and options in replay | Stocks yes, options not mentioned | No |
| History | 2 years on Pro, 5 to 7+ years on Premium (its own pages differ) | Up to 11 years of 1-minute candles |
| Replay | Tick-by-tick at 0.5x to 10x, or 1 to 30 minutes per second | Up to 200x on 1-minute candles |
| Level 2 and tick charts | Premium | No order book, no tick data |
| Fees in the simulator | Configurable, taken out of fills | Not modelled |
| Journal | Tags, equity curve, MFE and MAE, exports | Every replay trade logged with session stats and notes |
TradingSim facts from its plans page and features page, checked 19 November 2026. Traders Journal facts from our pricing page. Plans move, so trust their page over ours.
Traders Journal keeps backtesting sessions, performance statistics, trade entry, and post-trade notes in one workflow.
How We Compared
We build Traders Journal, so read our column with healthy suspicion. To keep it fair, we opened TradingSim's own plans and features pages on 19 November 2026 and noted four things: what it costs, which markets it covers, how much history each plan has, and what the simulator does with fees. We did not run a month-long hands-on test of TradingSim, so this is a spec-and-workflow comparison. Where its pages disagree with each other, such as how many years Premium covers, we say so instead of picking a number. No affiliate links. Nobody paid to be on this page.
Who TradingSim Is Built For
TradingSim is built for the trader who wants to relive the US stock open again and again. It has a deep symbol list, Level 2 on Premium, tick charts, and fee settings that make a result look like a real account. If you scalp small-cap momentum, it is made for you. TradingSim does cover futures and crypto, but if you trade forex or gold it has no forex, and Nasdaq futures are a side feature of a stock tool.
What TradingSim Does Better
We build Traders Journal, so here is the honest part first. TradingSim is the better tool if you:
- Trade US stocks. About 21,700 symbols, including stocks we do not replay at all.
- Need Level 2 and tick charts. Premium has both. We have neither.
- Want fees in the result. TradingSim lets you set commissions and takes them out of fills. Our replay does not model fees, margin or slippage, so treat our results as an upper bound.
If those three describe you, close this tab. Genuinely.
Where Traders Journal Is the Better Fit
- Forex, gold and index futures. TradingSim does not list forex. We replay EUR/USD, gold, oil and the CME and CBOT E-mini NQ, ES and YM, plus index CFDs like NAS100 and US30.
- Price. $396 a year is the TradingSim Pro price, $33 times 12. Our Premium is $119 a year, about 70% less, and the free plan costs nothing.
- No trial clock on the free plan. The free plan does not expire, so you can practise for a month and decide later. Premium adds a 21-day trial.
- Free replay and a free journal. Every replay trade lands in a journal with session stats on the free plan, so the review is done when the session ends.
Want a full trading day in minutes? Try our fake day trading simulator, which replays CME E-mini sessions for free. Or open the full Traders Journal trading journal and see how the replay and journal connect.
Replay Speed and How Many Reps You Get
TradingSim replays tick by tick at 0.5x to 10x, or fast-forwards 1 to 30 minutes per second. That is good for studying one entry closely. Our replay steps one 1-minute candle at a time, or plays at up to 200x, so a 6.5-hour cash session (390 minutes) passes in about two minutes at full speed. Different modes, different jobs. Tick-level study wants TradingSim. A pile of full-session reps wants fast candle replay.
Traders Journal's pricing page on 13 November 2026: Free at $0 with 10 backtesting sessions a day, Premium at $12 a month with a 21-day trial.
What a Practice Stop Costs on Index Futures
Many people searching for a TradingSim alternative trade index futures, so here is a number from our own data. We measured the first 30 minutes of the New York open on NAS100, using 15-minute OANDA candles over the last 250 complete trading days (20 August 2025 to 17 November 2026). The median range was about 170 points. At $20 a point on one NQ contract, a stop that wide costs $3,398. On one micro, MNQ at $2 a point, it costs $340.
NAS100 opening-range width over the last 250 complete trading days, 20 August 2025 to 17 November 2026. Past data, not a trade signal.
OANDA's NAS100 is a CFD that tracks the Nasdaq-100, not the CME NQ contract, and the dollar values are CME's. Days with missing candles were skipped, which removes every Friday, so this is a Monday to Thursday sample. No simulator makes that cost feel real, so size your practice account like your real one. More in our free futures trading simulator guide.
Switching From TradingSim: 3 Steps
- Export your TradingSim journal. It offers CSV, Excel and PDF exports.
- Try the free plan on one market. Pick one symbol and replay a week of sessions before you decide.
- Import or re-log your trades. Traders Journal has an Import CSV option on its Add New Trade form. Check the columns match before you rely on it.
Other TradingSim Alternatives Worth Knowing
- FX Replay. Browser replay with a free Beginner plan, paid plans at $17.99 and $35 a month.
- Forex Tester. Paid software with tick-level history and a free demo.
- TradingView. Free paper trading on live prices. Intraday bar replay needs a paid plan.
- Live paper accounts. thinkorswim and Webull are free and cover stocks. Our best day trading simulators guide compares them.
Which Should You Pick?
- US stocks, Level 2, fees in the result: TradingSim.
- Forex, gold or index futures on a budget: Traders Journal, free first.
- Both: start free here, and take TradingSim's 7-day trial for the stock days.
Either way, replay a few hundred sessions and write down why you took every trade. Replay your first session free, or read how paper trading simulators compare.
Frequently asked questions
01Is there a free alternative to TradingSim?
Yes. Traders Journal's free plan has no end date and gives 10 replay sessions a day, one symbol and a 90-day range on 1-minute candles. It covers forex, gold, oil, crypto, CME and CBOT E-mini futures and Indian indices, not US stocks or options. TradingSim itself has a 7-day trial.
02How much does TradingSim cost?
On its plans page, checked 19 November 2026, Pro is $33 a month and Premium $37 a month, both billed annually, with a 7-day free trial. That is $396 and $444 a year. Check the page, because plans change.
03Does TradingSim support forex?
Its plans and features pages list US stocks, futures and crypto, and do not mention forex. If forex is your main market, a forex-first replay tool such as Traders Journal, FX Replay or Forex Tester is a closer fit.
04Is Traders Journal cheaper than TradingSim?
Yes. Premium is $12 a month or $119 a year, against $396 a year for TradingSim Pro billed annually, and the free plan costs nothing. The tools cover different markets, so price is only half the choice.
05What does TradingSim do better than Traders Journal?
It replays US stocks, about 21,700 symbols, offers Level 2 and tick charts on Premium, and lets you set fees that come out of fills. Traders Journal does not replay individual US stocks or options, has no order book or tick data, and does not model fees.
06Can I replay futures on Traders Journal?
Yes. The replay covers CME and CBOT E-mini NQ, ES and YM, plus index CFDs such as DAX, Nikkei, US30, NAS100 and SPX500, on 1-minute candles at up to 200x. Gold and WTI crude are spot prices, not futures contracts.
07How much history does each tool have?
TradingSim lists 2 years on Pro and 5 to 7+ years on Premium, and its own pages disagree on the exact figure. Traders Journal lists up to 11 years of 1-minute history, with a 90-day range per session on the free plan and unlimited on Premium.
08Which should I choose, TradingSim or Traders Journal?
US stocks, Level 2 or fees in the result: TradingSim. Forex, gold or index futures on a budget, with a journal in the same account: Traders Journal. You can also use both, starting free here.
Test it with zero money on the line
Free candle replay, trade journaling and session stats in one workspace.
Small refundable charge. Cancel anytime — your trades stay yours.
More comparisons
- TradingView vs Traders JournalBrowser charts with a huge indicator library and bar replay.
- TradeZella vs Traders JournalJournal with broker sync, reports and trade replay.
- FX Replay vs Traders JournalBrowser market replay for manual backtesting.
- Forex Tester vs Traders JournalBacktesting software with historical tick data.